Advertisement

The Efficacy of Movement Representation Techniques for Treatment of Limb Pain—A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

  • Holm Thieme
    Correspondence
    Address reprint requests to Dr. Holm Thieme, PhD, Faculty of Social Work and Health, University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Goschentor 1, Hildesheim 31134, Germany.
    Affiliations
    Faculty of Social Work and Health, University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Hildesheim, Germany

    First European School for Physiotherapy, Occupational Therapy, and Speech and Language Therapy, Clinic Bavaria Kreischa, Kreischa, Germany
    Search for articles by this author
  • Nadine Morkisch
    Affiliations
    MEDIAN Clinic Berlin-Kladow, Berlin, Germany

    Center for Stroke Research Berlin, Charité – University Medicine Berlin, Berlin, Germany
    Search for articles by this author
  • Christian Rietz
    Affiliations
    Department of Special Education and Rehabilitation, Faculty of Human Sciences, University of Cologne, Germany
    Search for articles by this author
  • Christian Dohle
    Affiliations
    MEDIAN Clinic Berlin-Kladow, Berlin, Germany

    Center for Stroke Research Berlin, Charité – University Medicine Berlin, Berlin, Germany
    Search for articles by this author
  • Bernhard Borgetto
    Affiliations
    Faculty of Social Work and Health, University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Hildesheim, Germany
    Search for articles by this author
Published:November 06, 2015DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2015.10.015

      Highlights

      • We systematically reviewed the effects of movement representation on limb pain.
      • Overall, observation and imagination of movements reduced limb pain and disability.
      • We found good evidence for mirror therapy and motor imagery.
      • We found no evidence for phantom limb pain and poststroke pain.
      • Major limitations were small number of trials and sample sizes, and heterogeneity.

      Abstract

      Relatively new evidence suggests that movement representation techniques (ie, therapies that use the observation and/or imagination of normal pain-free movements, such as mirror therapy, motor imagery, or movement and/or action observation) might be effective in reduction of some types of limb pain. To summarize the evidence regarding the efficacy of those techniques, a systematic review with meta-analysis was performed. We searched Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, AMED, PsychINFO, Physiotherapy Evidence Database, and OT-seeker up to August 2014 and hand-searched further relevant resources for randomized controlled trials that studied the efficacy of movement representation techniques in reduction of limb pain. The outcomes of interest were pain, disability, and quality of life. Study selection and data extraction were performed by 2 reviewers independently. We included 15 trials on the effects of mirror therapy, (graded) motor imagery, and action observation in patients with complex regional pain syndrome, phantom limb pain, poststroke pain, and nonpathological (acute) pain. Overall, movement representation techniques were found to be effective in reduction of pain (standardized mean difference [SMD] = −.82, 95% confidence interval [CI], −1.32 to −.31, P = .001) and disability (SMD = .72, 95% CI, .22–1.22, P = .004) and showed a positive but nonsignificant effect on quality of life (SMD = 2.61, 85% CI, −3.32 to 8.54, P = .39). Especially mirror therapy and graded motor imagery should be considered for the treatment of patients with complex regional pain syndrome. Furthermore, the results indicate that motor imagery could be considered as a potential effective treatment in patients with acute pain after trauma and surgery. To date, there is no evidence for a pain reducing effect of movement representation techniques in patients with phantom limb pain and poststroke pain other than complex regional pain syndrome.

      Perspective

      In this systematic review we synthesize the evidence for the efficacy of movement representation techniques (ie, motor imagery, mirror therapy, or action observation) for treatment of limb pain. Our findings suggest effective pain reduction in some types of limb pain. Further research should address specific questions on the optimal type and dose of therapy.

      Key words

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment
      Subscribe to The Journal of Pain
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Acerra N.E.
        Is early post-stroke upper limb mirror therapy associated with improved sensation and motor recovery? A randomised-controlled trial. Sensorimotor dysfunction in CRPS1 and stroke: characteristics, prediction and intervention [Doctoral thesis].
        University of Queensland, Australia2007
        • Attal N.
        • Cruccu G.
        • Baron R.
        • Haanpaa M.
        • Hansson P.
        • Jensen T.S.
        • Nurmikko T.
        EFNS guidelines on the pharmacological treatment of neuropathic pain: 2010 revision.
        Eur J Neurol. 2010; 17 (1113–e88)
        • Bellelli G.
        • Buccino G.
        • Bernardini B.
        • Padovani A.
        • Trabucchi M.
        Action observation treatment improves recovery of postsurgical orthopedic patients: Evidence for a top-down effect?.
        Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2010; 91: 1489-1494
        • Bowering K.J.
        • O’Connell N.E.
        • Tabor A.
        • Catley M.J.
        • Leake H.B.
        • Moseley G.L.
        • Stanton T.R.
        The effects of graded motor imagery and its components on chronic pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
        J Pain. 2013; 14: 3-13
        • Breivik E.K.
        • Bjornsson G.A.
        • Skovlund E.
        A comparison of pain rating scales by sampling from clinical trial data.
        Clin J Pain. 2000; 16: 22-28
        • Breivik H.
        • Borchgrevink P.C.
        • Allen S.M.
        • Rosseland L.A.
        • Romundstad L.
        • Hals E.K.
        • Breivik E.K.
        • Kvarstein G.
        • Stubhaug A.
        Assessment of pain.
        Br J Anaesth. 2008; 101: 17-24
        • Brodie E.E.
        • Whyte A.
        • Niven C.A.
        Analgesia through the looking-glass? A randomized controlled trial investigating the effect of viewing a ‘virtual’ limb upon phantom limb pain, sensation and movement.
        Eur J Pain. 2007; 11: 428-436
        • Buccino G.
        Action observation treatment: A novel tool in neurorehabilitation.
        Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2014; 369: 20130185
        • Cacchio A.
        • De Blasis E.
        • De Blasis V.
        • Santilli V.
        • Spacca G.
        Mirror therapy in complex regional pain syndrome type 1 of the upper limb in stroke patients.
        Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2009; 23: 792-799
        • Cacchio A.
        • De Blasis E.
        • Necozione S.
        • di Orio F.
        • Santilli V.
        Mirror therapy for chronic complex regional pain syndrome type 1 and stroke.
        N Engl J Med. 2009; 361: 634-636
        • Celnik P.
        • Webster B.
        • Glasser D.M.
        • Cohen L.G.
        Effects of action observation on physical training after stroke.
        Stroke. 2008; 39: 1814-1820
        • Chan B.L.
        • Witt R.
        • Charrow A.P.
        • Magee A.
        • Howard R.
        • Pasquina P.F.
        • Heilman K.M.
        • Tsao J.W.
        Mirror therapy for phantom limb pain.
        New Engl J Med. 2007; 357: 2206-2207
        • Chapman C.R.
        • Stillman M.
        Pathologic pain.
        in: Krüger L. Pain and Touch: A Volume in Handbook of Perception and Cognition. Elsevier Science, New York1996: 315-342
        • Christakou A.
        • Zervas Y.
        The effectiveness of imagery on pain, edema, and range of motion in athletes with a grade II ankle sprain.
        Phys Ther Sport. 2007; 8: 130-140
        • Decety J.
        The neurophysiological basis of motor imagery.
        Behav Brain Res. 1996; 77: 45-52
        • Dickstein R.
        • Deutsch J.E.
        Motor imagery in physical therapist practice.
        Phys Ther. 2007; 87: 942-953
        • Dohle C.
        • Püllen J.
        • Nakaten A.
        • Küst J.
        • Rietz C.
        • Karbe H.
        Mirror therapy promotes recovery from severe hemiparesis: A randomized controlled trial.
        Neurorehab Neural Repair. 2009; 23: 209-217
        • Dworkin R.H.
        • O’Connor A.B.
        • Audette J.
        • Baron R.
        • Gourlay G.K.
        • Haanpaa M.L.
        • Kent J.L.
        • Krane E.J.
        • Lebel A.A.
        • Levy R.M.
        • Mackey S.C.
        • Mayer J.
        • Miaskowski C.
        • Raja S.N.
        • Rice A.S.
        • Schmader K.E.
        • Stacey B.
        • Stanos S.
        • Treede R.D.
        • Turk D.C.
        • Walco G.A.
        • Wells C.D.
        Recommendations for the pharmacological management of neuropathic pain: An overview and literature update.
        Mayo Clin Proc. 2010; 85: S3-S14
        • Dworkin R.H.
        • O’Connor A.B.
        • Kent J.
        • Mackey S.C.
        • Raja S.N.
        • Stacey B.R.
        • Levy R.M.
        • Backonja M.
        • Baron R.
        • Harke H.
        • Loeser J.D.
        • Treede R.D.
        • Turk D.C.
        • Wells C.D.
        Interventional management of neuropathic pain: NeuPSIG recommendations.
        Pain. 2013; 154: 2249-2261
        • Ezendam D.
        • Bongers R.M.
        • Jannink M.J.
        Systematic review of the effectiveness of mirror therapy in upper extremity function.
        Disabil Rehabil. 2009; 31: 2135-2149
        • Finnerup N.B.
        • Otto M.
        • Jensen T.S.
        • Sindrup S.H.
        An evidence-based algorithm for the treatment of neuropathic pain.
        MedGenMed. 2007; 9: 36
        • Flor H.
        • Elbert T.
        • Knecht S.
        • Wienbruch C.
        • Pantev C.
        • Birbaumer N.
        • Larbig W.
        • Taub E.
        Phantom-limb pain as a perceptual correlate of cortical reorganization following arm amputation.
        Nature. 1995; 375: 482-484
        • Galer B.S.
        • Henderson J.
        • Perander J.
        • Jensen M.P.
        Course of symptoms and quality of life measurement in complex regional pain syndrome: A pilot survey.
        J Pain Symptom Manage. 2000; 20: 286-292
        • Gaskin D.J.
        • Richard P.
        The economic costs of pain in the United States.
        J Pain. 2012; 13: 715-724
        • Giraux P.
        • Sirigu A.
        Illusory movements of the paralyzed limb restore motor cortex activity.
        Neuroimage. 2003; 20: 107-111
        • Gore M.
        • Brandenburg N.A.
        • Dukes E.
        • Hoffman D.L.
        • Tai K.
        • Stacey B.
        Pain severity in diabetic peripheral neuropathy is associated with patient functioning, symptom levels of anxiety and depression, and sleep.
        J Pain Symptom Manage. 2005; 30: 374-385
        • Gore M.
        • Brandenburg N.A.
        • Hoffman D.L.
        • Tai K.
        • Stacey B.
        Burden of illness in painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy: The patients’ perspectives.
        J Pain. 2006; 7: 892-900
        • Gustorff B.
        • Dorner T.
        • Likar R.
        • Grisold W.
        • Lawrence K.
        • Schwarz F.
        • Rieder A.
        Prevalence of self-reported neuropathic pain and impact on quality of life: A prospective representative survey.
        Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2008; 52: 132-136
        • Holen J.C.
        • Hjermstad M.J.
        • Loge J.H.
        • Fayers P.M.
        • Caraceni A.
        • de Conno F.
        • Forbes K.
        • Fürst C.J.
        • Radbruch L.
        • Kaasa S.
        Pain assessment tools: Is the content appropriate for use in palliative care?.
        J Pain Symptom Manage. 2006; 32: 567-580
        • Hoyek N.
        • di Rienzo F.
        • Collet C.
        • Hoyek F.
        • Guillot A.
        The therapeutic role of motor imagery on the functional rehabilitation of a stage II shoulder impingement syndrome.
        Disabil Rehabil. 2014; 36: 1113-1119
        • Jensen T.S.
        • Finnerup N.B.
        Management of neuropathic pain.
        Curr Opin Support Palliat Care. 2007; 1: 126-131
      1. Kumar SP, Kumar KV, Misri ZK, Kotian P: Effectiveness of graded motor imagery and mirror therapy in patients with unilateral upper extremity complex regional pain syndrome type-1: A pilot quasi-experimental study. Presented at the World Congress of NeuroRehabilitation (WCNR), May 16–19, 2012, Melbourne, Australia

        • Lebon F.
        • Guillot A.
        • Collet C.
        Increased muscle activation following motor imagery during the rehabilitation of the anterior cruciate ligament.
        Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 2012; 37: 45-51
        • MacIver K.
        • Lloyd D.M.
        • Kelly S.
        • Roberts N.
        • Nurmikko T.
        Phantom limb pain, cortical reorganization and the therapeutic effect of mental imagery.
        Brain. 2008; 131: 2181-2191
        • Maher C.G.
        • Sherrington C.
        • Herbert R.D.
        • Moseley A.M.
        • Elkins M.
        Reliability of the PEDro scale for rating quality of randomized controlled trials.
        Phys Ther. 2003; 83: 713-721
        • Maihöfner C.
        • Handwerker H.O.
        • Neundörfer B.
        • Birklein F.
        Patterns of cortical reorganization in complex regional pain syndrome.
        Neurology. 2003; 61: 1707-1715
        • Manca A.
        • Eldabe S.
        • Buchser E.
        • Kumar K.
        • Taylor R.S.
        Relationship between health-related quality of life, pain, and functional disability in neuropathic pain patients with failed back surgery syndrome.
        Value Health. 2010; 13: 95-102
        • McCabe C.S.
        • Haigh R.C.
        • Ring E.F.
        • Halligan P.W.
        • Wall P.D.
        • Blake D.R.
        A controlled pilot study of the utility of mirror visual feedback in the treatment of complex regional pain syndrome (type 1).
        Rheumatology. 2003; 42: 97-101
      2. Michenthaler MC: Effectiveness of Mirror Therapy in Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS): A functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) supported, double blinded RCT to the clinic-psychological status of affected patients before and after Therapy [doctoral thesis, in German]. Klagenfurt, Alpen – Adria – Universität Klagenfurt; 2013

        • Michielsen M.E.
        • Selles R.W.
        • van der Geest J.N.
        • Eckhardt M.
        • Yavuzer G.
        • Stam H.J.
        • Smits M.
        • Ribbers G.M.
        • Bussmann J.B.
        Motor recovery and cortical reorganisation after mirror therapy in chronic stroke patients: A phase II randomized controlled trial.
        Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2011; 25: 223-233
        • Moseley G.L.
        Graded motor imagery for pathologic pain: A randomized controlled trial.
        Neurology. 2006; 67: 2129-2134
        • Moseley G.L.
        Graded motor imagery is effective for long-standing complex regional pain syndrome: A randomised controlled trial.
        Pain. 2004; 108: 192-198
        • Moseley G.L.
        Is successful rehabilitation of complex regional pain syndrome due to sustained attention to the affected limb? A randomised clinical trial.
        Pain. 2005; 114: 54-61
        • Moseley G.L.
        • Flor H.
        Targeting cortical representations in the treatment of chronic pain: A review.
        Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2012; 26: 646-652
        • Nemeth G.
        Health related quality of life outcome instruments.
        Eur Spine J. 2006; 15: S44-S51
        • O’Connor A.B.
        • Dworkin R.H.
        Treatment of neuropathic pain: An overview of recent guidelines.
        Am J Med. 2009; 122: S22-S32
        • O’Connell N.E.
        • Wand B.M.
        • McAuley J.
        • Marston L.
        • Moseley G.L.
        Interventions for treating pain and disability in adults with complex regional pain syndrome.
        Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013; 4: CD009416
        • Park S.D.
        • Song H.S.
        • Kim J.Y.
        The effect of action observation training on knee joint function and gait ability in total knee replacement patients.
        J Exerc Rehabil. 2014; 10: 168-171
        • Pelosin E.
        • Bove M.
        • Ruggeri P.
        • Avanzino L.
        • Abbruzzese G.
        Reduction of bradykinesia of finger movements by a single session of action observation in Parkinson disease.
        Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2013; 27: 552-560
        • Perry B.N.
        • Hussey-Andersen L.K.
        • Hughes K.E.
        • Weeks S.R.
        • Merritt V.C.
        • Pasquina P.F.
        • Tsao J.W.
        Mirror therapy as a phantom limb pain treatment for upper-extremity amputees.
        J Neurol. 2013; (Conference: 23rd Meeting of the European Neurological Society, Barcelona Spain): S19
        • Ramachandran V.S.
        Phantom limbs, neglect syndromes, repressed memories, and Freudian psychology.
        Int Rev Neurobiol. 1994; 37: 291-333
        • Ramachandran V.S.
        • Rogers-Ramachandran D.
        • Cobb S.
        Touching the phantom limb.
        Nature. 1995; 377: 489-490
        • Rothgangel A.S.
        • Braun S.M.
        • Beurskens A.J.
        • Seitz R.J.
        • Wade D.T.
        The clinical aspects of mirror therapy in rehabilitation: A systematic review of the literature.
        Int J Rehabil Res. 2011; 34: 1-13
        • Savas S.
        • Baloglu H.H.
        • Ay G.
        • Cerci S.S.
        The effect of sequel symptoms and signs of complex regional pain syndrome type 1 on upper extremity disability and quality of life.
        Rheumatol Int. 2009; 29: 545-550
        • Seidel S.
        • Kasprian G.
        • Sycha T.
        • Auff E.
        Mirror therapy for phantom limb pain–a systematic review.
        Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2009; 121: 440-444
      3. Stein R: Influence of non-pharmacological interventions (repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation or mirror therapy) on pain intensity and pain associated central nervous plasticity in patients with phantom limb pain [doctoral thesis, in German]. Bochum, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, 2012

        • Straube S.
        • Derry S.
        • Moore R.A.
        • McQuay H.J.
        Cervico-thoracic or lumbar sympathectomy for neuropathic pain and complex regional pain syndrome.
        Cochrane Database Syst Rev 7. 2010; : CD002918
        • Sumitani M.
        • Miyauchi S.
        • McCabe C.S.
        • Shibata M.
        • Maeda L.
        • Saitoh Y.
        • Tashiro T.
        • Mashimo T.
        Mirror visual feedback alleviates deafferentation pain, depending on qualitative aspects of the pain: A preliminary report.
        Rheumatology. 2008; 47: 1038-1043
        • Swart C.M.
        • Stins J.F.
        • Beek P.J.
        Cortical changes in complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS).
        Eur J Pain. 2009; 13: 902-907
        • Thieme H.
        • Mehrholz J.
        • Pohl M.
        • Behrens J.
        • Dohle C.
        Mirror therapy for improving motor function after stroke.
        Cochrane Database Syst Rev 3. 2012; : CD008449
        • Ulger O.
        • Topuz S.
        • Bayramlar K.
        • Sener G.
        • Erbahceci F.
        Effectiveness of phantom exercises for phantom limb pain: A pilot study.
        J Rehabil Med. 2009; 41: 582-584
        • Villiger M.
        • Bohli D.
        • Kiper D.
        • Pyk P.
        • Spillmann J.
        • Meilick B.
        • Curt A.
        • Hepp-Reymond M.C.
        • Hotz-Boendermaker S.
        • Eng K.
        Virtual reality-augmented neurorehabilitation improves motor function and reduces neuropathic pain in incomplete spinal cord injury patients.
        Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2013; 27: 675-683
        • Zimmermann-Schlatter A.
        • Schuster C.
        • Puhan M.A.
        • Siekierka E.
        • Steurer J.
        Efficacy of motor imagery in post-stroke rehabilitation: A systematic review.
        J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2008; 5: 8

      Linked Article

      • Erratum
        The Journal of PainVol. 17Issue 6
        • Preview
          Two sentences with incorrect information appeared in Thieme H, Morkisch N, Rietz C, Dohle C, Borgetto B: Management of postoperative pain: The efficacy of movement representation techniques for treatment of limb pain—a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Pain 17:167-180, 2016.
        • Full-Text
        • PDF