Advertisement

A Systematic Review of Cross-Cultural Comparison Studies of Child, Parent, and Health Professional Outcomes Associated With Pediatric Medical Procedures

      Abstract

      The purpose of this review was to evaluate systematically all published and unpublished research concerning culture and medical procedural pain in children. Databases, reference lists, and electronic list servers were searched as data sources. Fifteen studies met the inclusion criteria. Most studies (80%) were conducted solely in the United States comparing Caucasian American groups to other local subculture(s) (ie, African American, Hispanic, or Japanese). The studies compared, cross culturally, pediatric pain-related outcomes in children, parents and/or health professionals. The medical procedural experiences included surgery, immunization, spinal tap, bone marrow aspiration, needle procedures, orthopedic, and wound-related injuries. The evidence published to date suggests that cultural factors may be associated with children’s pain experiences when elicited by medical procedural pain, specifically children’s pain behavior. Nevertheless, research using more sophisticated research methods is needed to develop culturally sensitive behavioral pain measures. Measures that include physiological pain parameters in addition to other behavioral outcomes may be helpful. Culturally comparative research would benefit from the use of theoretical frameworks to advance our understanding of the cultural underpinnings of child pain development and guide future research.

      Perspective

      The current evidence supports that children and parents belonging to cultural minority groups, and in need of health care, are a vulnerable population. Together, researchers and clinicians are encouraged to explore this understudied area, and take advantage of sophisticated methods developed by disciplines like cross-cultural psychology.

      Key words

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to The Journal of Pain
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Albertyn R.
        • van Djik M.
        • Tibboel D.
        • de Liefde I.
        • Bosenberg A.T.
        • Rode H.
        • Thomas J.
        Infant pain in developing countries: A South African perspective, in Anand KJS.
        in: Stevens B.J. McGrath P.J. Pain In Neonates and Infants: Pain Research and Clinical Management. Elsevier, Edinburgh, SCT2007: 263-271
      1. American Dietetic Association: ADA evidence analysis manual. Available at: http://www.adaevidencelibrary.com/topic.cfm?cat=1155&auth=1. Accessed November 3, 2006

        • American Psychological Association
        Guidelines on multicultural education, training, research, practice, and organizational change for psychologists.
        Am Psychol. 2003; 58: 377-402
        • Bauchner H.
        • Vinci R.
        • Waring C.
        Pediatric procedures: Do parents want to watch?.
        Pediatrics. 1989; 84: 907-909
        • Bernstein B.A.
        • Pachter L.M.
        Cultural considerations in children’s pain.
        in: Schechter N.L. Berde C.B. Yaster M. Pain In infants, Children, and Adolescents. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia, PA2003: 142-156
        • Bernstein B.A.
        • Pachter L.M.
        Cultural considerations in children’s pain, in Schechter NL.
        in: Berde C.B. Yaster M. Pain In Infants, Children and, Adolescents. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia, PA1993: 113-122
        • Berry J.W.
        • Poortinga Y.H.
        • Segall M.H.
        • Dasen P.R.
        Cross-Cultural Psychology: Research and Applications.
        Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA2002 (pp 317-341)
        • Beyer J.E.
        The Oucher: A pain intensity scale for children.
        in: Funk S.G. Tornquist M.T. Champagne M.T. Copp L.A. Wiese R.A. Key Aspects of Comfort. Springer, New York, NY1989: 65-71
        • Beyer J.E.
        The Oucher: A User’s Manual and Technical Report.
        The Hospital Play Equipment Company, Evanston, IL1984
        • Beyer J.E.
        • Denyes M.J.
        • Villarruel A.M.
        The creation, validation, and continuing development of the Oucher: A measure of pain intensity in children.
        J Pediatr Nurs. 1992; 7: 335-346
        • Beyer J.E.
        • Turner S.B.
        • Jones L.
        • Young L.
        • Onikul R.
        • Bohaty B.
        The alternate forms reliability of the Oucher pain scale.
        Pain Manag Nurs. 2005; 6: 10-17
        • Bhopal R.
        Glossary of terms relating to ethnicity and race: For reflection and debate.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2004; 58: 441-445
        • Bohannon A.S.
        Physiological, self report and behavioral ratings of pain in three to seven year old African American and Anglo American children.
        The University of Miami, Coral Cables, FL1995
        • Bradby H.
        Describing ethnicity in health research.
        Ethn Health. 2003; 8: 5-13
        • Calvillo E.R.
        • Flaskerud J.H.
        Review of literature on culture and pain of adults with focus on Mexican-Americans.
        J Transcult Nurs. 1991; 2: 16-23
        • Comstock R.D.
        • Castillo E.M.
        • Lindsay S.P.
        Four-year review of the use of race and ethnicity in epidemiologic and public health research.
        Am J Epidemiol. 2004; 159: 611-619
        • Craig K.D.
        Social modeling influences: Pain in context.
        in: Sternback R. The Psychology of Pain. Raven Press, New York, NY1986: 67-95
        • Craig K.D.
        Pillai Riddell RR: Social influences, culture, and ethnicity.
        in: McGrath P.J. Finley G.A. Pediatric Pain: Biological and Social Context. IASP Press, Seattle, WA2003: 159-182
        • David M.
        • Pant H.A.
        • Oligmuller A.K.
        • Babitsch B.
        • Borde T.
        Ethnic Differences in Reported Pain Regions - Results of a Survey at Three Clinical Emergency Rooms in Berlin/Germany.
        Geburtshilfe Und Frauenheilkunde. 2011; 71: 44-52
        • Devins G.M.
        • Gupta A.
        • Cameron J.
        • Woodend K.
        • Mah K.
        • Gladman D.
        Cultural syndromes and age moderate the emotional impact of illness intrusiveness in rheumatoid arthritis.
        Rehabil Psychol. 2009; 54: 33-44
        • Deyo R.A.
        • Diehl A.K.
        • Hazuda H.
        • Stern M.P.
        A simple language-based acculturation scale for Mexican Americans: Validation and application to health care research.
        Am J Public Health. 1985; 75: 51-55
        • Egede L.E.
        Race, ethnicity, culture, and disparities in health care.
        J Gen Intern Med. 2006; 21: 667-669
        • Ezenwa M.O.
        • Ameringer S.
        • Ward S.E.
        • Serlin R.C.
        Racial and ethnic disparities in pain management in the United States.
        J Nurs Scholarsh. 2006; 38: 225-233
        • Faucett J.
        • Gordon N.
        • Levine J.
        Differences in postoperative pain severity among four ethnic groups.
        J Pain Symptom Manage. 1994; 9: 383-389
        • Finley G.A.
        • Kristjansdottir O.
        • Forgeron P.A.
        Cultural influences on the assessment of children’s pain.
        Pain Res Manag. 2009; 14: 33-37
        • Flores G.
        Technical report–racial and ethnic disparities in the health and health care of children.
        Pediatrics. 2010; 125: e979-e1020
        • Flores G.
        • Abreu M.
        • Schwartz I.
        • Hill M.
        The importance of language and culture in pediatric care: Case studies from the Latino community.
        J Pediatr. 2000; 137: 842-848
        • Foster S.L.
        • Martinez Jr., C.R.
        Ethnicity: Conceptual and methodological issues in child clinical research.
        J Clin Child Psychol. 1995; 24: 214-226
        • Green C.R.
        • Anderson K.O.
        • Baker T.A.
        • Campbell L.C.
        • Decker S.
        • Fillingim R.B.
        • Kaloukalani D.A.
        • Lasch K.E.
        • Myers C.
        • Tait R.C.
        • Todd K.H.
        • Vallerand A.H.
        The unequal burden of pain: Confronting racial and ethnic disparities in pain.
        Pain Med. 2003; 4: 277-294
        • Grunau R.V.
        • Craig K.D.
        Pain expression in neonates: Facial action and cry.
        Pain. 1987; 28: 395-410
        • He H.
        Exporting the cultural roots of parenting: European American and mainland Chinese parenting beliefs, goals, and practices.
        Washington State University, WA, Pullman, WA2004
        • Hermann C.
        • Hohmeister J.
        • Demirakca S.
        • Zohsel K.
        • Flor H.
        Long-term alteration of pain sensitivity in school-aged children with early pain experiences.
        Pain. 2006; 125: 278-285
        • Hester N.K.
        The preoperational child’s reaction to immunization.
        Nurs Res. 1979; 28: 250-255
        • Hilton A.
        • Skrutkowski M.
        Translating instruments into other languages: Development and testing processes.
        Cancer Nurs. 2002; 25: 1-7
        • Holdsworth M.T.
        • Raisch D.W.
        • Chavez C.H.
        • Leasure M.M.
        • Duncan M.H.
        Ethnic and observational variables in procedure-related pain in children.
        Clin Pharmacol Ther. 1994; 55: 178
        • Hostetler M.A.
        • Auinger P.
        • Szilagyi P.G.
        Parenteral analgesic and sedative use among ED patients in the United States: Combined results from the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NHAMCS) 1992-1997.
        Am J Emerg Med. 2002; 20: 139-143
        • Hsieh A.Y.
        • Tripp D.A.
        • Ji L.-J.
        The influence of ethnic concordance and discordance on verbal reports and nonverbal behaviours of pain.
        Pain. 2011; 152: 2016-2022
        • Hwang C.
        • Yan W.
        • Scherer R.
        Understanding managerial behavior in different cultures: A review of instrument translation methodology.
        IJM. 1996; 13: 332-339
        • Jimenez N.
        • Seidel K.
        • Martin L.D.
        • Rivara F.P.
        • Lynn A.M.
        Perioperative analgesic treatment in Latino and non-Latino pediatric patients.
        J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2010; 21: 229-236
        • Johnson T.P.
        Methods and frameworks for cross cultural measurement.
        Med Care. 2006; 44: S17-S20
        • Jones M.
        • Qazi M.
        • Young K.D.
        Ethnic differences in parent preference to be present for painful medical procedures.
        Pediatrics. 2005; 116: e191-e197
        • Jordan-Marsh M.
        • Yoder L.
        • Hall D.
        • Watson R.
        Alternate Oucher form testing: Gender, ethnicity, and age variations.
        Res Nurs Health. 1994; 17: 111-118
        • Kao H.F.
        • Hsu M.T.
        • Clark L.
        Conceptualizing and critiquing culture in health research.
        J Transcult Nurs. 2004; 15: 269-277
        • Kaplan J.B.
        • Bennett T.
        Use of race and ethnicity in biomedical publication.
        JAMA. 2003; 289: 2709-2716
        • Karpman R.R.
        • Del Mar N.
        • Bay C.
        Analgesia for emergency centers’ orthopaedic patients: Does an ethnic bias exist?.
        Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1997 Jan; : 270-275
        • Katz E.R.
        • Kellerman J.
        • Siegel S.E.
        Behavioral distress in children with cancer undergoing medical procedures: Developmental considerations.
        J Consult Clin Psychol. 1980; 48: 356-365
        • Kuttner L.
        Management of young children’s acute pain and anxiety during invasive medical procedures.
        Pediatrician. 1989; 16: 39-44
        • Kuttner L.
        • LePage T.
        Face scales for the assessment of pediatric pain: A critical review.
        Can J Behav Sci. 1989; 21: 198-209
        • Lasch K.E.
        Culture and pain.
        Pain Clin Update. 2002; 10: 1-9
        • LeBaron S.
        • Zeltzer L.
        Assessment of acute pain and anxiety in children and adolescents by self-reports, observer reports, and a behavior checklist.
        J Consult Clin Psychol. 1984; 52: 729-738
        • Lewis M.
        Culture and biology: The role of temperament.
        in: Zelazo P.R. Barr R.G. Challenges To Developmental Paradigms: Implications For Theory, Assessment and Treatment. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ1989: 203-223
        • Lewis M.
        • Ramsay D.S.
        • Kawakami K.
        Differences between Japanese infants and Caucasian American infants in behavioral and cortisol response to inoculation.
        Child Dev. 1993; 64: 1722-1731
        • Lewit E.M.
        • Baker L.G.
        Race and ethnicity–changes for children.
        Future Child. 1994; 4: 134-144
        • Mahoney L.
        • Ayers S.
        • Seddon P.
        The association between parent’s and healthcare professional’s behavior and children’s coping and distress during venepuncture.
        J Pediatr Psychol. 2010; 35: 985-995
        • McCarty C.A.
        • Weisz J.R.
        • Wanitromanee K.
        • Eastman K.L.
        • Suwanlert S.
        • Chaiyasit W.
        • Band E.B.
        Culture, coping, and context: Primary and secondary control among Thai and American youth.
        J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 1999; 40: 809-818
        • McGrath P.
        • Johnson C.
        • Goodman J.
        • Schillinger J.
        • Dunn J.
        • Chapman J.
        CHEOPS: A behavioral scale for rating postoperative pain in children, in Fields HL.
        in: Dubner R. Cervero F. Advances In Pain Research and Therapy. Raven Press, New York, NY1985: 395-402
        • McGrath P.A.
        Pain In Children: Nature, Assessment and Treatment.
        The Guilford Press, New York, NY1990
        • McGrath P.J.
        • Unruh A.M.
        Pain In Children and Adolescents.
        Elsevier, Amsterdam, NL1987
        • McMurtry C.M.
        • Chambers C.T.
        • McGrath P.J.
        • Asp E.
        When “don’t worry” communicates fear: Children’s perceptions of parental reassurance and distraction during a painful medical procedure.
        Pain. 2010; 150: 52-58
        • Milenkovic P.H.
        • Read C.
        Speech Supplement User’s Manual: Speech Version 3.1.
        University of Wisconsin-Madison Press, Madison, WI1990
        • Morris D.B.
        Ethnicity and pain.
        Pain Clin updates. 2001; 9: 1-8
        • Mossey J.
        Defining racial and ethnic disparities in pain management.
        Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2011; 469: 1859-1870
        • Neuman B.M.
        Relationships between children’s descriptions of pain, self-care and dependent-care, and basic conditioning factors of development, gender, and ethnicity: “Bears in my throat”.
        Wayne State University, Detroit, MI1996
        • Okazaki S.
        • Sue S.
        Methodological issues in assessment research with ethnic minorities.
        Psychol Assess. 1995; 7: 367-375
        • Pfefferbaum B.
        • Adams J.
        • Aceves J.
        The influence of culture on pain in Anglo and Hispanic children with cancer.
        J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1990; 29: 642-647
        • Rosmus C.
        • Johnston C.C.
        • Chan-Yip A.
        • Yang F.
        Pain response in Chinese and non-Chinese Canadian infants: Is there a difference?.
        Soc Sci Med. 2000; 51: 175-184
        • Shavers V.L.
        • Bakos A.
        • Sheppard V.B.
        Race, ethnicity, and pain among the US adult population.
        J Health Care Poor U. 2010; 21: 177-220
        • Spielberger C.D.
        Manual for the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory.
        Consulting Psychologists Press, Palo Alto, CA1983
        • Spielberger C.D.
        • Edwards C.D.
        • Lushene R.E.
        • Montuori J.
        • Platzek D.
        STAIC Preliminary Manual.
        Consulting Psychologists Press, Palo Alto, CA1973
        • Streiner D.L.
        • Norman G.R.
        Health Measurement Scales: A Practical Guide to Their Development and Use.
        Oxford University Press, New York, NY2003 (pp 127-152)
        • Suinn R.M.
        • Rickard-Figueroa K.
        • Lew S.
        • Vigil P.
        The Suinn-Lew Asian self-identity ascculturation scale: An initial report.
        Educ Psychol Meas. 1987; 47: 401-407
        • Taddio A.
        • Chambers C.T.
        • Halperin S.A.
        • Ipp M.
        • Lockett D.
        • Rieder M.J.
        • Shah V.
        Inadequate pain management during routine childhood immunizations: The nerve of it.
        Clin Ther. 2009; 31: S152-S167
        • Triandis H.C.
        Culture and psychology: A history of the study of their relationship.
        in: Kitayama S. Cohen D. Handbook of Cultural Psychology. Guilford Press, New York, NY2007: 59-76
      2. UNICEF and World Health Organization: Immunization summary. A statististical reference containing data through 2009: UNICEF Statistics and Monitoring Section. Available at: http://www.childinfo.org/files/32775_UNICEF.pdf. Accessed April 12, 2011

        • van Aken M.A.
        • van Lieshout C.F.
        • Katz E.R.
        • Heezen T.J.
        Development of behavioral distress in reaction to acute pain in two cultures.
        J Pediatr Psychol. 1989; 14: 421-432
        • van de Vijver F.J.
        • Leung K.
        Personality in cultural context: Methodological issues.
        J Pers. 2001; 69: 1007-1031
        • VanderBeek B.
        • Mehlman C.
        • Foad S.
        • Wall E.
        • Crawford A.
        The use of conscious sedation for pain control during forearm fracture reduction in children: Does race matter?.
        J Pediatr Orthop. 2006; 26: 53-57
        • Waltz C.F.
        • Strickland O.L.
        • Lenz E.R.
        Measurement in Nursing and Health Research.
        Springer Publishing Company, New York, NY2005 (pp 380-414)
        • Watson P.J.
        • Latif R.K.
        • Rowbotham D.J.
        Ethnic differences in thermal pain responses: A comparison of South Asian and White British healthy males.
        Pain. 2005; 118: 194-200
        • Weisman S.J.
        • Bernstein B.
        • Schechter N.L.
        Consequences of inadequate analgesia during painful procedures in children.
        Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998; 152: 147-149
        • Wilkinson D.Y.
        • King G.
        Conceptual and methodological issues in the use of race as a variable: Policy implications.
        Milbank Q. 1987; 65: 56-71
        • Wong D.
        • Baker C.
        Pain in children: Comparison of assessment scales.
        Okla Nurse. 1988; 33: 8
        • Yen K.
        • Kim M.
        • Stremski E.S.
        • Gorelick M.H.
        Effect of ethnicity and race on the use of pain medications in children with long bone fractures in the emergency department.
        Ann Emerg Med. 2003; 42: 41-47
        • Zborowski M.
        Cultural components in responses to pain.
        J Soc Issues. 1952; 8: 16-30
        • Zola I.K.
        Culture and symptoms–an analysis of patient’s presenting complaints.
        Am Sociol Rev. 1966; 31: 615-630