Advertisement

Acupuncture for Chronic Pain: Update of an Individual Patient Data Meta-Analysis

Published:November 30, 2017DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2017.11.005

      Highlights

      • Acupuncture has a clinically relevant effect on chronic pain that persists over time.
      • The effect of acupuncture cannot be explained only by placebo effects.
      • Factors in addition to the specific effects of needling are important contributors.
      • Referral for acupuncture treatment is a reasonable option for chronic pain patients.

      Abstract

      Despite wide use in clinical practice, acupuncture remains a controversial treatment for chronic pain. Our objective was to update an individual patient data meta-analysis to determine the effect size of acupuncture for 4 chronic pain conditions. We searched MEDLINE and the Cochrane Central Registry of Controlled Trials randomized trials published up until December 31, 2015. We included randomized trials of acupuncture needling versus either sham acupuncture or no acupuncture control for nonspecific musculoskeletal pain, osteoarthritis, chronic headache, or shoulder pain. Trials were only included if allocation concealment was unambiguously determined to be adequate. Raw data were obtained from study authors and entered into an individual patient data meta-analysis. The main outcome measures were pain and function. An additional 13 trials were identified, with data received for a total of 20,827 patients from 39 trials. Acupuncture was superior to sham as well as no acupuncture control for each pain condition (all P < .001) with differences between groups close to .5 SDs compared with no acupuncture control and close to .2 SDs compared with sham. We also found clear evidence that the effects of acupuncture persist over time with only a small decrease, approximately 15%, in treatment effect at 1 year. In secondary analyses, we found no obvious association between trial outcome and characteristics of acupuncture treatment, but effect sizes of acupuncture were associated with the type of control group, with smaller effects sizes for sham controlled trials that used a penetrating needle for sham, and for trials that had high intensity of intervention in the control arm. We conclude that acupuncture is effective for the treatment of chronic pain, with treatment effects persisting over time. Although factors in addition to the specific effects of needling at correct acupuncture point locations are important contributors to the treatment effect, decreases in pain after acupuncture cannot be explained solely in terms of placebo effects. Variations in the effect size of acupuncture in different trials are driven predominantly by differences in treatments received by the control group rather than by differences in the characteristics of acupuncture treatment.

      Perspective

      Acupuncture is effective for the treatment of chronic musculoskeletal, headache, and osteoarthritis pain. Treatment effects of acupuncture persist over time and cannot be explained solely in terms of placebo effects. Referral for a course of acupuncture treatment is a reasonable option for a patient with chronic pain.

      Key words

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to The Journal of Pain
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Ahn C.B.
        • Lee S.J.
        • Lee J.C.
        • Fossion J.P.
        • Sant'Ana A.
        A clinical pilot study comparing traditional acupuncture to combined acupuncture for treating headache, trigeminal neuralgia and retro-auricular pain in facial palsy.
        J Acupunct Meridian Stud. 2011; 4: 29-43
        • Ahsin S.
        • Saleem S.
        • Bhatti A.M.
        • Iles R.K.
        • Aslam M.
        Clinical and endocrinological changes after electro-acupuncture treatment in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee.
        Pain. 2009; 147: 60-66
        • Allais G.
        • Romoli M.
        • Rolando S.
        • Airola G.
        • Castagnoli Gabellari I.
        • Allais R.
        • Benedetto C.
        Ear acupuncture in the treatment of migraine attacks: A randomized trial on the efficacy of appropriate versus inappropriate acupoints.
        Neurol Sci. 2011; 32: S173-S175
        • Allam H.
        • Mohammed N.H.
        The role of scalp acupuncture for relieving the chronic pain of degenerative osteoarthritis: A pilot study of Egyptian women.
        Med Acupunct. 2013; 25: 216-220
        • Aranha M.F.
        • Muller C.E.
        • Gaviao M.B.
        Pain intensity and cervical range of motion in women with myofascial pain treated with acupuncture and electroacupuncture: A double-blinded, randomized clinical trial.
        Braz J PhysTher. 2014; 19: 34-43
        • Ashraf A.
        • Zarei F.
        • Hadianfard M.J.
        • Kazemi B.
        • Mohammadi S.
        • Naseri M.
        • Nasseri A.
        • Khodadadi M.
        • Sayadi M.
        Comparison the effect of lateral wedge insole and acupuncture in medial compartment knee osteoarthritis: A randomized controlled trial.
        Knee. 2014; 21: 439-444
        • Baeumler P.I.
        • Fleckenstein J.
        • Takayama S.
        • Simang M.
        • Seki T.
        • Irnich D.
        Effects of acupuncture on sensory perception: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
        PLoS One. 2014; 9 (e113731)
        • Berman B.M.
        • Lao L.
        • Langenberg P.
        • Lee W.L.
        • Gilpin A.M.
        • Hochberg M.C.
        Effectiveness of acupuncture as adjunctive therapy in osteoarthritis of the knee: A randomized, controlled trial.
        Ann Intern Med. 2004; 141: 901-910
        • Birch S.
        A review and analysis of placebo treatments, placebo effects, and placebo controls in trials of medical procedures when sham is not inert.
        J Altern Complement Med. 2006; 12: 303-310
        • Bjordal J.M.
        • Ljunggren A.E.
        • Klovning A.
        • Slordal L.
        Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, including cyclo-oxygenase-2 inhibitors, in osteoarthritic knee pain: Meta-analysis of randomised placebo controlled trials.
        BMJ. 2004; 329: 1317
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Jena S.
        • Linde K.
        • Streng A.
        • Wagenpfeil S.
        • Irnich D.
        • Walther H.U.
        • Melchart D.
        • Willich S.N.
        Acupuncture in patients with chronic low back pain: A randomized controlled trial.
        Arch Intern Med. 2006; 166: 450-457
        • Cameron I.D.
        • Wang E.
        • Sindhusake D.
        A randomized trial comparing acupuncture and simulated acupuncture for subacute and chronic whiplash.
        Spine. 2011; 36: E1659-E1665
        • Carlsson C.P.
        • Sjolund B.H.
        Acupuncture for chronic low back pain: A randomized placebo-controlled study with long-term follow-up.
        Clin J Pain. 2001; 17: 296-305
        • Chassot M.
        • Dussan-Sarria J.A.
        • Sehn F.C.
        • Deitos A.
        • de Souza A.
        • Vercelino R.
        • Torres I.L.
        • Fregni F.
        • Caumo W.
        Electroacupuncture analgesia is associated with increased serum brain-derived neurotrophic factor in chronic tension-type headache: A randomized, sham controlled, crossover trial.
        BMC Complement Altern Med. 2015; 15: 144
        • Chen C.C.
        • Yang C.C.
        • Hu C.C.
        • Shih H.N.
        • Chang Y.H.
        • Hsieh P.H.
        Acupuncture for pain relief after total knee arthroplasty: A randomized controlled trial.
        Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2015; 40: 31-36
        • Chen L.X.
        • Mao J.J.
        • Fernandes S.
        • Galantino M.L.
        • Guo W.
        • Lariccia P.
        • Teal V.L.
        • Bowman M.A.
        • Schumacher H.R.
        • Farrar J.T.
        Integrating acupuncture with exercise-based physical therapy for knee osteoarthritis: A randomized controlled trial.
        J Clin Rheumatol. 2013; 19: 308-316
        • Chen X.
        • Spaeth R.B.
        • Freeman S.G.
        • Scarborough D.M.
        • Hashmi J.A.
        • Wey H.Y.
        • Egorova N.
        • Vangel M.
        • Mao J.
        • Wasan A.D.
        • Edwards R.R.
        • Gollub R.L.
        • Kong J.
        The modulation effect of longitudinal acupuncture on resting state functional connectivity in knee osteoarthritis patients.
        Mol Pain. 2015; 11: 67
        • Cherkin D.C.
        • Eisenberg D.
        • Sherman K.J.
        • Barlow W.
        • Kaptchuk T.J.
        • Street J.
        • Deyo R.A.
        Randomized trial comparing traditional Chinese medical acupuncture, therapeutic massage, and self-care education for chronic low back pain.
        Arch Intern Med. 2001; 161: 1081-1088
        • Cherkin D.C.
        • Sherman K.J.
        • Avins A.L.
        • Erro J.H.
        • Ichikawa L.
        • Barlow W.E.
        • Delaney K.
        • Hawkes R.
        • Hamilton L.
        • Pressman A.
        • Khalsa P.S.
        • Deyo R.A.
        A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain.
        Arch Intern Med. 2009; 169: 858-866
        • Cho J.H.
        • Nam D.H.
        • Kim K.T.
        • Lee J.H.
        Acupuncture with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) versus acupuncture or NSAIDs alone for the treatment of chronic neck pain: An assessor-blinded randomised controlled pilot study.
        Acupunct Med. 2014; 32: 17-23
        • Cho Y.J.
        • Song Y.K.
        • Cha Y.Y.
        • Shin B.C.
        • Shin I.H.
        • Park H.J.
        • Lee H.S.
        • Kim K.W.
        • Cho J.H.
        • Chung W.S.
        • Lee J.H.
        • Song M.Y.
        Acupuncture for chronic low back pain: A multicenter, randomized, patient-assessor blind, sham-controlled clinical trial.
        Spine. 2013; 38: 549-557
        • Chou L.W.
        • Hsieh Y.L.
        • Chen H.S.
        • Hong C.Z.
        • Kao M.J.
        • Han T.I.
        Remote therapeutic effectiveness of acupuncture in treating myofascial trigger point of the upper trapezius muscle.
        Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2011; 90: 1036-1049
        • Coeytaux R.R.
        • Kaufman J.S.
        • Kaptchuk T.J.
        • Chen W.
        • Miller W.C.
        • Callahan L.F.
        • Mann J.D.
        A randomized, controlled trial of acupuncture for chronic daily headache.
        Headache. 2005; 45: 1113-1123
        • D'Alessandro E.
        • de Brito C.
        • Cecatto R.
        • Saul M.
        • Atta J.A.
        • Lin C.A.
        Evaluation of acupuncture for cancer symptoms in a cancer institute in Brazil.
        Acupunct Med. 2013; 31: 23-26
        • De Kooning M.
        • Tobbackx Y.
        • Meeus M.
        • Wauters L.
        • Ickmans K.
        • De Vilder P.
        • Roose J.
        • Verhaeghe T.
        • Nijs J.
        Acupuncture-analgesia following a single treatment session in chronic whiplash is unrelated to autonomic nervous system changes: A randomized cross-over trial.
        Pain Physician. 2015; 18: 527-536
        • Diener H.C.
        • Kronfeld K.
        • Boewing G.
        • Lungenhausen M.
        • Maier C.
        • Molsberger A.
        • Tegenthoff M.
        • Trampisch H.J.
        • Zenz M.
        • Meinert R.
        Efficacy of acupuncture for the prophylaxis of migraine: A multicentre randomised controlled clinical trial.
        Lancet Neurol. 2006; 5: 310-316
        • Egorova N.
        • Gollub R.L.
        • Kong J.
        Repeated verum but not placebo acupuncture normalizes connectivity in brain regions dysregulated in chronic pain.
        Neuroimage Clin. 2015; 9: 430-435
        • Endres H.G.
        • Bowing G.
        • Diener H.C.
        • Lange S.
        • Maier C.
        • Molsberger A.
        • Zenz M.
        • Vickers A.J.
        • Tegenthoff M.
        Acupuncture for tension-type headache: A multicentre, sham-controlled, patient-and observer-blinded, randomised trial.
        J Headache Pain. 2007; 8: 306-314
        • Enthoven W.T.
        • Roelofs P.D.
        • Deyo R.A.
        • van Tulder M.W.
        • Koes B.W.
        Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for chronic low back pain.
        Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016; (CD012087)
        • Facco E.
        • Liguori A.
        • Petti F.
        • Fauci A.J.
        • Cavallin F.
        • Zanette G.
        Acupuncture versus valproic acid in the prophylaxis of migraine without aura: A prospective controlled study.
        Minerva Anestesiol. 2013; 79: 634-642
        • Ferro E.C.
        • Biagini A.P.
        • da Silva I.E.
        • Silva M.L.
        • Silva J.R.
        The combined effect of acupuncture and Tanacetum parthenium on quality of life in women with headache: Randomised study.
        Acupunct Med. 2012; 30: 252-257
        • Foroughipour M.
        • Golchian A.R.
        • Kalhor M.
        • Akhlaghi S.
        • Farzadfard M.T.
        • Azizi H.
        A sham-controlled trial of acupuncture as an adjunct in migraine prophylaxis.
        Acupunct Med. 2014; 32: 12-16
        • Foster N.E.
        • Thomas E.
        • Barlas P.
        • Hill J.C.
        • Young J.
        • Mason E.
        • Hay E.M.
        Acupuncture as an adjunct to exercise based physiotherapy for osteoarthritis of the knee: Randomised controlled trial.
        BMJ. 2007; 335: 436
        • Grotle M.
        Traditional Chinese acupuncture was not superior to sham acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis but delivering treatment with high expectations of improvement was superior to delivering treatment with neutral expectations.
        J Physiother. 2011; 57: 56
        • Guerra de Hoyos J.A.
        • Andres Martin Mdel C.
        • Bassas y Baena de Leon E.
        • Vigara Lopez M.
        • Molina Lopez T.
        • Verdugo Morilla F.A.
        • Gonzalez Moreno M.J.
        Randomised trial of long term effect of acupuncture for shoulder pain.
        Pain. 2004; 112: 289-298
        • Haake M.
        • Muller H.H.
        • Schade-Brittinger C.
        • Basler H.D.
        • Schafer H.
        • Maier C.
        • Endres H.G.
        • Trampisch H.J.
        • Molsberger A.
        German Acupuncture Trials (GERAC) for chronic low back pain: Randomized, multicenter, blinded, parallel-group trial with 3 groups.
        Arch Intern Med. 2007; 167: 1892-1898
        • Hansson Y.
        • Carlsson C.
        • Olsson E.
        Intramuscular and periosteal acupuncture in patients suffering from chronic musculoskeletal pain—A controlled trial.
        Acupunct Med. 2008; 26: 214-223
        • Hasegawa T.M.
        • Baptista A.S.
        • de Souza M.C.
        • Yoshizumi A.M.
        • Natour J.
        Acupuncture for acute non-specific low back pain: A randomised, controlled, double-blind, placebo trial.
        Acupunct Med. 2014; 32: 109-115
        • Hinman R.S.
        • McCrory P.
        • Pirotta M.
        • Relf I.
        • Forbes A.
        • Crossley K.M.
        • Williamson E.
        • Kyriakides M.
        • Novy K.
        • Metcalf B.R.
        • Harris A.
        • Reddy P.
        • Conaghan P.G.
        • Bennell K.L.
        Acupuncture for chronic knee pain: A randomized clinical trial.
        JAMA. 2014; 312: 1313-1322
        • Hunter R.F.
        • McDonough S.M.
        • Bradbury I.
        • Liddle S.D.
        • Walsh D.M.
        • Dhamija S.
        • Glasgow P.
        • Gormley G.
        • McCann S.M.
        • Park J.
        • Hurley D.A.
        • Delitto A.
        • Baxter G.D.
        Exercise and auricular acupuncture for chronic low-back pain: A feasibility randomized-controlled trial.
        Clin J Pain. 2012; 28: 259-267
        • Irnich D.
        • Behrens N.
        • Molzen H.
        • Konig A.
        • Gleditsch J.
        • Krauss M.
        • Natalis M.
        • Senn E.
        • Beyer A.
        • Schops P.
        Randomised trial of acupuncture compared with conventional massage and “sham” laser acupuncture for treatment of chronic neck pain.
        BMJ. 2001; 322: 1574-1578
        • Itoh K.
        • Saito S.
        • Sahara S.
        • Naitoh Y.
        • Imai K.
        • Kitakoji H.
        Randomized trial of trigger point acupuncture treatment for chronic shoulder pain: A preliminary study.
        J Acupunct Meridian Stud. 2014; 7: 59-64
        • Jena S.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Wegscheider K.
        • Willich S.N.
        Acupuncture in patients with headache.
        Cephalalgia. 2008; 28: 969-979
        • Ji L.
        • Wang H.
        • Cao Y.
        • Yan P.
        • Jin X.
        • Nie P.
        • Wang C.
        • Li R.
        • Zhang C.
        • Yang M.
        • Yang J.
        Sharp-Hook Acupuncture (Feng Gou Zhen) for patients with periarthritis of shoulder: A randomized controlled trial.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2015; 312309: 2015
        • Johansson K.
        • Bergstrom A.
        • Schroder K.
        • Foldevi M.
        Subacromial corticosteroid injection or acupuncture with home exercises when treating patients with subacromial impingement in primary care—A randomized clinical trial.
        Fam Pract. 2011; 28: 355-365
        • Kaptchuk T.J.
        • Stason W.B.
        • Davis R.B.
        • Legedza A.R.
        • Schnyer R.N.
        • Kerr C.E.
        • Stone D.A.
        • Nam B.H.
        • Kirsch I.
        • Goldman R.H.
        Sham device v inert pill: Randomised controlled trial of two placebo treatments.
        BMJ. 2006; 332: 391-397
        • Karner M.
        • Brazkiewicz F.
        • Remppis A.
        • Fischer J.
        • Gerlach O.
        • Stremmel W.
        • Subramanian S.V.
        • Greten H.J.
        Objectifying specific and nonspecific effects of acupuncture: A double-blinded randomised trial in osteoarthritis of the knee.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2013; 2013: 427265
        • Kennedy S.
        • Baxter G.D.
        • Kerr D.P.
        • Bradbury I.
        • Park J.
        • McDonough S.M.
        Acupuncture for acute non-specific low back pain: A pilot randomised non-penetrating sham controlled trial.
        Complement Ther Med. 2008; 16: 139-146
        • Kerr D.P.
        • Walsh D.M.
        • Baxter D.
        Acupuncture in the management of chronic low back pain: A blinded randomized controlled trial.
        Clin J Pain. 2003; 19: 364-370
        • Kim E.J.
        • Lim C.Y.
        • Lee E.Y.
        • Lee S.D.
        • Kim K.S.
        Comparing the effects of individualized, standard, sham and no acupuncture in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis: A multicenter randomized controlled trial.
        Trials. 2013; 14: 129
        • Kim J.I.
        • Kim T.H.
        • Lee M.S.
        • Kang J.W.
        • Kim K.H.
        • Choi J.Y.
        • Kang K.W.
        • Kim A.R.
        • Shin M.S.
        • Jung S.Y.
        • Choi S.M.
        Evaluation of wet-cupping therapy for persistent non-specific low back pain: A randomised, waiting-list controlled, open-label, parallel-group pilot trial.
        Trials. 2011; 12: 146
        • Kleinhenz J.
        • Streitberger K.
        • Windeler J.
        • Gussbacher A.
        • Mavridis G.
        • Martin E.
        Randomised clinical trial comparing the effects of acupuncture and a newly designed placebo needle in rotator cuff tendinitis.
        Pain. 1999; 83: 235-241
        • Koh P.S.
        • Seo B.K.
        • Cho N.S.
        • Park H.S.
        • Park D.S.
        • Baek Y.H.
        Clinical effectiveness of bee venom acupuncture and physiotherapy in the treatment of adhesive capsulitis: A randomized controlled trial.
        J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2013; 22: 1053-1062
        • Kong J.
        • Spaeth R.
        • Cook A.
        • Kirsch I.
        • Claggett B.
        • Vangel M.
        • Gollub R.L.
        • Smoller J.W.
        • Kaptchuk T.J.
        Are all placebo effects equal? Placebo pills, sham acupuncture, cue conditioning and their association.
        PLoS One. 2013; 8 (e67485)
        • Lan L.
        • Gao Y.
        • Zeng F.
        • Qin W.
        • Dong M.
        • Liu M.
        • Guo T.
        • Liang F.
        A central analgesic mechanism of acupuncture for migraine: An ongoing functional MRI study.
        Neural Regen Res. 2013; 8: 2649-2655
        • Lansdown H.
        • Howard K.
        • Brealey S.
        • MacPherson H.
        Acupuncture for pain and osteoarthritis of the knee: A pilot study for an open parallel-arm randomised controlled trial.
        BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2009; 10: 130
        • Lathia A.T.
        • Jung S.M.
        • Chen L.X.
        Efficacy of acupuncture as a treatment for chronic shoulder pain.
        J Altern Complement Med. 2009; 15: 613-618
        • Li N.
        • Tian F.
        • Wang C.
        • Yu P.
        • Zhou X.
        • Wen Q.
        • Qiao X.
        • Huang L.
        Therapeutic effect of acupuncture and massage for shoulder-hand syndrome in hemiplegia patients: A clinical two-center randomized controlled trial.
        J Tradit Chin Med. 2012; 32: 343-349
        • Li Y.
        • Zheng H.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Roll S.
        • Yu S.G.
        • Yan J.
        • Sun G.J.
        • Zhao L.
        • Huang W.J.
        • Chang X.R.
        • Zhang H.X.
        • Wang D.J.
        • Lan L.
        • Zou R.
        • Liang F.R.
        Acupuncture for migraine prophylaxis: A randomized controlled trial.
        CMAJ. 2012; 184: 401-410
        • Liang Z.
        • Zhu X.
        • Yang X.
        • Fu W.
        • Lu A.
        Assessment of a traditional acupuncture therapy for chronic neck pain: A pilot randomised controlled study.
        Complement Ther Med. 2011; 19: S26-S32
        • Lin M.L.
        • Lin M.H.
        • Fen J.J.
        • Lin W.T.
        • Lin C.W.
        • Chen P.Q.
        A comparison between pulsed radiofrequency and electro-acupuncture for relieving pain in patients with chronic low back pain.
        Acupunct Electrother Res. 2010; 35: 133-146
        • Lin M.L.
        • Wu H.C.
        • Hsieh Y.H.
        • Su C.T.
        • Shih Y.S.
        • Lin C.W.
        • Wu J.H.
        Evaluation of the effect of laser acupuncture and cupping with ryodoraku and visual analog scale on low back pain.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2012; 2012: 521612
        • Linde K.
        • Streng A.
        • Jurgens S.
        • Hoppe A.
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Witt C.
        • Wagenpfeil S.
        • Pfaffenrath V.
        • Hammes M.G.
        • Weidenhammer W.
        • Willich S.N.
        • Melchart D.
        Acupuncture for patients with migraine: A randomized controlled trial.
        JAMA. 2005; 293: 2118-2125
        • Ma C.
        • Wu S.
        • Li G.
        • Xiao X.
        • Mai M.
        • Yan T.
        Comparison of miniscalpel-needle release, acupuncture needling, and stretching exercise to trigger point in myofascial pain syndrome.
        Clin J Pain. 2010; 26: 251-257
        • Macpherson H.
        • Scullion A.
        • Thomas K.J.
        • Walters S.
        Patient reports of adverse events associated with acupuncture treatment: A prospective national survey.
        Qual Saf Health Care. 2004; 13: 349-355
        • MacPherson H.
        • Maschino A.C.
        • Lewith G.
        • Foster N.E.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Vickers A.J.
        Characteristics of acupuncture treatment associated with outcome: An individual patient meta-analysis of 17,922 patients with chronic pain in randomised controlled trials.
        PLoS One. 2013; 8 (e77438)
        • MacPherson H.
        • Tilbrook H.
        • Richmond S.
        • Woodman J.
        • Ballard K.
        • Atkin K.
        • Bland M.
        • Eldred J.
        • Essex H.
        • Hewitt C.
        • Hopton A.
        • Keding A.
        • Lansdown H.
        • Parrott S.
        • Torgerson D.
        • Wenham A.
        • Watt I.
        Alexander Technique lessons or acupuncture sessions for persons with chronic neck pain: A randomized trial.
        Ann Intern Med. 2015; 163: 653-662
        • MacPherson H.
        • Vertosick E.
        • Lewith G.
        • Linde K.
        • Sherman K.J.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Vickers A.J.
        Influence of control group on effect size in trials of acupuncture for chronic pain: A secondary analysis of an individual patient data meta-analysis.
        PLoS One. 2014; 9 (e93739)
        • MacPherson H.
        • Vertosick E.A.
        • Foster N.E.
        • Lewith G.
        • Linde K.
        • Sherman K.J.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Vickers A.J.
        The persistence of the effects of acupuncture after a course of treatment: A meta-analysis of patients with chronic pain.
        Pain. 2016; 158: 784-793
        • Mavrommatis C.I.
        • Argyra E.
        • Vadalouka A.
        • Vasilakos D.G.
        Acupuncture as an adjunctive therapy to pharmacological treatment in patients with chronic pain due to osteoarthritis of the knee: A 3-armed, randomized, placebo-controlled trial.
        Pain. 2012; 153: 1720-1726
        • Melchart D.
        • Streng A.
        • Hoppe A.
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Witt C.
        • Wagenpfeil S.
        • Pfaffenrath V.
        • Hammes M.
        • Hummelsberger J.
        • Irnich D.
        • Weidenhammer W.
        • Willich S.N.
        • Linde K.
        Acupuncture in patients with tension-type headache: Randomised controlled trial.
        BMJ. 2005; 331: 376-382
        • Miller E.
        • Maimon Y.
        • Rosenblatt Y.
        • Mendler A.
        • Hasner A.
        • Barad A.
        • Amir H.
        • Dekel S.
        • Lev-Ari S.
        Delayed effect of acupuncture treatment in OA of the knee: A blinded, randomized, controlled trial.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2011; 2011: 792975
        • Miyazaki S.
        • Hagihara A.
        • Kanda R.
        • Mukaino Y.
        • Nobutomo K.
        Applicability of press needles to a double-blind trial: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial.
        Clin J Pain. 2009; 25: 438-444
        • Molsberger A.F.
        • Mau J.
        • Pawelec D.B.
        • Winkler J.
        Does acupuncture improve the orthopedic management of chronic low back pain—A randomized, blinded, controlled trial with 3 months follow up.
        Pain. 2002; 99: 579-587
        • Molsberger A.F.
        • Schneider T.
        • Gotthardt H.
        • Drabik A.
        German Randomized Acupuncture Trial for chronic shoulder pain (GRASP)—A pragmatic, controlled, patient-blinded, multi-centre trial in an outpatient care environment.
        Pain. 2010; 151: 146-154
        • Peets J.M.
        • Pomeranz B.
        CXBK mice deficient in opiate receptors show poor electroacupuncture analgesia.
        Nature. 1978; 273: 675-676
        • Sahin N.
        • Ozcan E.
        • Sezen K.
        • Karatas O.
        • Issever H.
        Efficacy of acupunture in patients with chronic neck pain—A randomised, sham controlled trial.
        Acupunct Electrother Res. 2010; 35: 17-27
        • Saleki M.
        • Ahadi T.
        • Razi M.
        • Raeisi G.R.
        • Forough B.
        • Ali M.K.
        Comparison of the effects of acupuncture and isometric exercises on symptom of knee osteoarthritis.
        Int J Prev Med. 2013; 4: S73-S77
        • Salter G.C.
        • Roman M.
        • Bland M.J.
        • MacPherson H.
        Acupuncture for chronic neck pain: A pilot for a randomised controlled trial.
        BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2006; 7: 99
        • Scharf H.P.
        • Mansmann U.
        • Streitberger K.
        • Witte S.
        • Kramer J.
        • Maier C.
        • Trampisch H.J.
        • Victor N.
        Acupuncture and knee osteoarthritis: A three-armed randomized trial.
        Ann Intern Med. 2006; 145: 12-20
        • Shankar N.
        • Thakur M.
        • Tandon O.P.
        • Saxena A.K.
        • Arora S.
        • Bhattacharya N.
        Autonomic status and pain profile in patients of chronic low back pain and following electro acupuncture therapy: A randomized control trial.
        Indian J Physiol Pharmacol. 2011; 55: 25-36
        • Silva A.C.
        • Biasotto-Gonzalez D.A.
        • Dos Santos D.M.
        • Melo N.C.
        • Gomes C.A.
        • Amorim C.F.
        • Politti F.
        Evaluation of the immediate effect of auricular acupuncture on pain and electromyographic activity of the upper trapezius muscle in patients with nonspecific neck pain: A randomized, single-blinded, sham-controlled, crossover study.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2015; 523851: 2015
        • Soderberg E.I.
        • Carlsson J.Y.
        • Stener-Victorin E.
        • Dahlof C.
        Subjective well-being in patients with chronic tension-type headache: Effect of acupuncture, physical training, and relaxation training.
        Clin J Pain. 2011; 27: 448-456
        • Spaeth R.B.
        • Camhi S.
        • Hashmi J.A.
        • Vangel M.
        • Wasan A.D.
        • Edwards R.R.
        • Gollub R.L.
        • Kong J.
        A longitudinal study of the reliability of acupuncture deqi sensations in knee osteoarthritis.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2013; 2013: 204259
        • Suarez-Almazor M.E.
        • Looney C.
        • Liu Y.
        • Cox V.
        • Pietz K.
        • Marcus D.M.
        • Street Jr, R.L.
        A randomized controlled trial of acupuncture for osteoarthritis of the knee: Effects of patient-provider communication.
        Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2010; 62: 1229-1236
        • Sun M.Y.
        • Hsieh C.L.
        • Cheng Y.Y.
        • Hung H.C.
        • Li T.C.
        • Yen S.M.
        • Huang I.S.
        The therapeutic effects of acupuncture on patients with chronic neck myofascial pain syndrome: A single-blind randomized controlled trial.
        Am J Chin Med. 2010; 38: 849-859
        • Thomas K.J.
        • MacPherson H.
        • Thorpe L.
        • Brazier J.
        • Fitter M.
        • Campbell M.J.
        • Roman M.
        • Walters S.J.
        • Nicholl J.
        Randomised controlled trial of a short course of traditional acupuncture compared with usual care for persistent non-specific low back pain.
        BMJ. 2006; 333: 623
        • Vas J.
        • Aranda J.M.
        • Modesto M.
        • Benitez-Parejo N.
        • Herrera A.
        • Martinez-Barquin D.M.
        • Aguilar I.
        • Sanchez-Araujo M.
        • Rivas-Ruiz F.
        Acupuncture in patients with acute low back pain: A multicentre randomised controlled clinical trial.
        Pain. 2012; 153: 1883-1889
        • Vas J.
        • Mendez C.
        • Perea-Milla E.
        • Vega E.
        • Panadero M.D.
        • Leon J.M.
        • Borge M.A.
        • Gaspar O.
        • Sanchez-Rodriguez F.
        • Aguilar I.
        • Jurado R.
        Acupuncture as a complementary therapy to the pharmacological treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee: Randomised controlled trial.
        BMJ. 2004; 329: 1216
        • Vas J.
        • Ortega C.
        • Olmo V.
        • Perez-Fernandez F.
        • Hernandez L.
        • Medina I.
        • Seminario J.M.
        • Herrera A.
        • Luna F.
        • Perea-Milla E.
        • Mendez C.
        • Madrazo F.
        • Jimenez C.
        • Ruiz M.A.
        • Aguilar I.
        Single-point acupuncture and physiotherapy for the treatment of painful shoulder: A multicentre randomized controlled trial.
        Rheumatology (Oxford). 2008; 47: 887-893
        • Vas J.
        • Perea-Milla E.
        • Mendez C.
        • Sanchez Navarro C.
        • Leon Rubio J.M.
        • Brioso M.
        • Garcia Obrero I.
        Efficacy and safety of acupuncture for chronic uncomplicated neck pain: A randomised controlled study.
        Pain. 2006; 126: 245-255
        • Vickers A.J.
        • Cronin A.M.
        • Maschino A.C.
        • Lewith G.
        • Macpherson H.
        • Victor N.
        • Sherman K.J.
        • Witt C.
        • Linde K.
        Individual patient data meta-analysis of acupuncture for chronic pain: Protocol of the Acupuncture Trialists' Collaboration.
        Trials. 2010; 11: 90
        • Vickers A.J.
        • Cronin A.M.
        • Maschino A.C.
        • Lewith G.
        • MacPherson H.
        • Foster N.E.
        • Sherman K.J.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Linde K.
        Acupuncture for chronic pain: Individual patient data meta-analysis.
        Arch Intern Med. 2012; 172: 1444-1453
        • Vickers A.J.
        • Maschino A.C.
        • Lewith G.
        • MacPherson H.
        • Sherman K.J.
        • Witt C.M.
        • Acupuncture Trialists C
        Responses to the Acupuncture Trialists' Collaboration individual patient data meta-analysis.
        Acupunct Med. 2013; 31: 98-100
        • Vickers A.J.
        • Rees R.W.
        • Zollman C.E.
        • McCarney R.
        • Smith C.M.
        • Ellis N.
        • Fisher P.
        • Van Haselen R.
        Acupuncture for chronic headache in primary care: Large, pragmatic, randomised trial.
        BMJ. 2004; 328: 744
        • Wallasch T.M.
        • Weinschuetz T.
        • Mueller B.
        • Kropp P.
        Cerebrovascular response in migraineurs during prophylactic treatment with acupuncture: A randomized controlled trial.
        J Altern Complement Med. 2012; 18: 777-783
        • Wand B.M.
        • Abbaszadeh S.
        • Smith A.J.
        • Catley M.J.
        • Moseley G.L.
        Acupuncture applied as a sensory discrimination training tool decreases movement-related pain in patients with chronic low back pain more than acupuncture alone: A randomised cross-over experiment.
        Br J Sports Med. 2013; 47: 1085-1089
        • Wang L.P.
        • Zhang X.Z.
        • Guo J.
        • Liu H.L.
        • Zhang Y.
        • Liu C.Z.
        • Yi J.H.
        • Wang L.P.
        • Zhao J.P.
        • Li S.S.
        Efficacy of acupuncture for migraine prophylaxis: A single-blinded, double-dummy, randomized controlled trial.
        Pain. 2011; 152: 1864-1871
        • Wang L.P.
        • Zhang X.Z.
        • Guo J.
        • Liu H.L.
        • Zhang Y.
        • Liu C.Z.
        • Yi J.H.
        • Wang L.P.
        • Zhao J.P.
        • Li S.S.
        Efficacy of acupuncture for acute migraine attack: A multicenter single blinded, randomized controlled trial.
        Pain Med. 2012; 13: 623-630
        • Wang Y.
        • Xue C.C.
        Acupuncture for frequent migraine: A randomized, patient/assessor blinded, controlled trial with one-year follow-up.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2015; 2015: 920353
        • Weiner D.K.
        • Moore C.G.
        • Morone N.E.
        • Lee E.S.
        • Kent Kwoh C.
        Efficacy of periosteal stimulation for chronic pain associated with advanced knee osteoarthritis: A randomized, controlled clinical trial.
        Clin Ther. 2013; 35 (e1705): 1703-1720
        • Weiss J.
        • Quante S.
        • Xue F.
        • Muche R.
        • Reuss-Borst M.
        Effectiveness and acceptance of acupuncture in patients with chronic low back pain: Results of a prospective, randomized, controlled trial.
        J Altern Complement Med. 2013; 19: 935-941
        • White P.
        • Bishop F.L.
        • Prescott P.
        • Scott C.
        • Little P.
        • Lewith G.
        Practice, practitioner, or placebo? A multifactorial, mixed-methods randomized controlled trial of acupuncture.
        Pain. 2012; 153: 455-462
        • White P.
        • Lewith G.
        • Prescott P.
        • Conway J.
        Acupuncture versus placebo for the treatment of chronic mechanical neck pain: A randomized, controlled trial.
        Ann Intern Med. 2004; 141: 911-919
        • Whitehurst D.G.
        • Bryan S.
        • Hay E.M.
        • Thomas E.
        • Young J.
        • Foster N.E.
        Cost-effectiveness of acupuncture care as an adjunct to exercise-based physical therapy for osteoarthritis of the knee.
        Phys Ther. 2011; 91: 630-641
        • Wilke J.
        • Vogt L.
        • Niederer D.
        • Hubscher M.
        • Rothmayr J.
        • Ivkovic D.
        • Rickert M.
        • Banzer W.
        Short-term effects of acupuncture and stretching on myofascial trigger point pain of the neck: A blinded, placebo-controlled RCT.
        Complement Ther Med. 2014; 22: 835-841
        • Williamson L.
        • Wyatt M.R.
        • Yein K.
        • Melton J.T.
        Severe knee osteoarthritis: A randomized controlled trial of acupuncture, physiotherapy (supervised exercise) and standard management for patients awaiting knee replacement.
        Rheumatology (Oxford). 2007; 46: 1445-1449
        • Witt C.
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Jena S.
        • Linde K.
        • Streng A.
        • Wagenpfeil S.
        • Hummelsberger J.
        • Walther H.U.
        • Melchart D.
        • Willich S.N.
        Acupuncture in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee: A randomised trial.
        Lancet. 2005; 366: 136-143
        • Witt C.M.
        • Jena S.
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Liecker B.
        • Wegscheider K.
        • Willich S.N.
        Acupuncture for patients with chronic neck pain.
        Pain. 2006; 125: 98-106
        • Witt C.M.
        • Jena S.
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Liecker B.
        • Wegscheider K.
        • Willich S.N.
        Acupuncture in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee or hip: A randomized, controlled trial with an additional nonrandomized arm.
        Arthritis Rheum. 2006; 54: 3485-3493
        • Witt C.M.
        • Jena S.
        • Selim D.
        • Brinkhaus B.
        • Reinhold T.
        • Wruck K.
        • Liecker B.
        • Linde K.
        • Wegscheider K.
        • Willich S.N.
        Pragmatic randomized trial evaluating the clinical and economic effectiveness of acupuncture for chronic low back pain.
        Am J Epidemiol. 2006; 164: 487-496
        • Witt C.M.
        • Schutzler L.
        • Ludtke R.
        • Wegscheider K.
        • Willich S.N.
        Patient characteristics and variation in treatment outcomes: Which patients benefit most from acupuncture for chronic pain?.
        Clin J Pain. 2011; 27: 550-555
        • Yang C.P.
        • Chang M.H.
        • Li T.C.
        • Hsieh C.L.
        • Hwang K.L.
        • Chang H.H.
        Predicting prognostic factors in a randomized controlled trial of acupuncture versus topiramate treatment in patients with chronic migraine.
        Clin J Pain. 2013; 29: 982-987
        • Yang C.P.
        • Chang M.H.
        • Liu P.E.
        • Li T.C.
        • Hsieh C.L.
        • Hwang K.L.
        • Chang H.H.
        Acupuncture versus topiramate in chronic migraine prophylaxis: A randomized clinical trial.
        Cephalalgia. 2011; 31: 1510-1521
        • Yang J.
        • Zeng F.
        • Feng Y.
        • Fang L.
        • Qin W.
        • Liu X.
        • Song W.
        • Xie H.
        • Chen J.
        • Liang F.
        A PET-CT study on the specificity of acupoints through acupuncture treatment in migraine patients.
        BMC Complement Altern Med. 2012; 12: 123
        • Yang M.
        • Yang J.
        • Zeng F.
        • Liu P.
        • Lai Z.
        • Deng S.
        • Fang L.
        • Song W.
        • Xie H.
        • Liang F.
        Electroacupuncture stimulation at sub-specific acupoint and non-acupoint induced distinct brain glucose metabolism change in migraineurs: A PET-CT study.
        J Transl Med. 2014; 12: 351
        • Yun M.
        • Shao Y.
        • Zhang Y.
        • He S.
        • Xiong N.
        • Zhang J.
        • Guo M.
        • Liu D.
        • Luo Y.
        • Guo L.
        • Yan J.
        Hegu acupuncture for chronic low-back pain: A randomized controlled trial.
        J Altern Complement Med. 2012; 18: 130-136
        • Zhang S.P.
        • Chiu T.T.
        • Chiu S.N.
        Long-term efficacy of electroacupuncture for chronic neck pain: A randomised controlled trial.
        Hong Kong Med J. 2013; 19: 36-39
        • Zhang W.T.
        • Jin Z.
        • Cui G.H.
        • Zhang K.L.
        • Zhang L.
        • Zeng Y.W.
        • Luo F.
        • Chen A.C.
        • Han J.S.
        Relations between brain network activation and analgesic effect induced by low vs. high frequency electrical acupoint stimulation in different subjects: A functional magnetic resonance imaging study.
        Brain Res. 2003; 982: 168-178
        • Zhao H.
        • Nie W.
        • Sun Y.
        • Li S.
        • Yang S.
        • Meng F.
        • Zhang L.
        • Wang F.
        • Huang S.
        Warm needling therapy and acupuncture at Meridian-Sinew sites based on the Meridian-Sinew Theory: Hemiplegic shoulder pain.
        Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2015; 2015: 694973
        • Zhao L.
        • Liu J.
        • Zhang F.
        • Dong X.
        • Peng Y.
        • Qin W.
        • Wu F.
        • Li Y.
        • Yuan K.
        • von Deneen K.M.
        • Gong Q.
        • Tang Z.
        • Liang F.
        Effects of long-term acupuncture treatment on resting-state brain activity in migraine patients: A randomized controlled trial on active acupoints and inactive acupoints.
        PLoS One. 2014; 9 (e99538)