Advertisement

Is Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) Effective for the Treatment of Pain in Fibromyalgia? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Published:January 23, 2020DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2020.01.003

      Highlights

      • We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) for fibromyalgia pain.
      • There is tentative evidence of pain reduction when active tDCS is compared to sham.
      • Substantial heterogeneity and high risk of bias of primary studies was identified.
      • There is a need for more basic science research to guide future clinical studies

      Abstract

      Background: Fibromyalgia is a debilitating condition characterized by chronic widespread pain. It is believed to be caused by dysfunction of the central nervous system (CNS) but current treatments are largely ineffective. Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), a neuromodulation technique that targets the CNS, may offer a new line of treatment. Objective: To systematically review the most up-to-date literature and perform a meta-analysis of the effects of tDCS on pain intensity in fibromyalgia. Methods: The following databases were searched from inception: Medline (Ovid), PsychInfo, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science. Studies were eligible if they were randomized controlled trials, quasi-randomized trials, and nonrandomized. Crossover and parallel-group design studies were included. Risk of bias was assessed for all included studies. Meta-analysis was conducted on studies investigating pain intensity after tDCS in participants with fibromyalgia and analyzed using standardized mean difference and 95% confidence intervals. Results: Fourteen clinical studies were included. Ten were controlled trials and 4 were within-subjects crossover studies. Meta-analysis of data from 8 controlled trials provides tentative evidence of pain reduction when active tDCS is delivered compared to sham. However, substantial statistical heterogeneity and high risk of bias of primary studies prevent more conclusive recommendations being made. Conclusions: tDCS is a safe intervention with the potential to lower pain intensity in fibromyalgia. However, there is a need for more empirical research of the neural target sites and optimum stimulation parameters to achieve the greatest effects before conducting further clinical studies.

      Perspective

      This systematic review and meta-analysis synthesizes current evidence for the clinical effectiveness of tDCS in the treatment of fibromyalgia pain. There is only tentative evidence of pain reduction when active tDCS is compared to sham. High heterogeneity and risk of bias across studies suggest a need for further empirical research.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic and Personal

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to The Journal of Pain
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Accornero N
        • Voti PL
        • La Riccia M
        • Gregori B
        Visual evoked potentials modulation during direct current cortical polarization.
        Exp Brain Res. 2007; 178: 261-266
        • Ahn S
        • Prim JH
        • Alexander ML
        • McCulloch KL
        • Frohlich F
        Identifying and engaging neuronal oscillations by transcranial alternating current stimulation in patients with chronic low back pain: A randomized, crossover, double-blind, sham-controlled pilot study.
        J Pain. 2019; 20 (277.e271-277.e211)
        • Arendsen LJ
        • Hugh-Jones S
        • Lloyd DM
        Transcranial alternating current stimulation at alpha frequency reduces pain when the intensity of pain is uncertain.
        J Pain. 2018; 19: 807-818
        • Bikson M
        • Datta A
        • Rahman A
        • Scaturro J
        Electrode montages for tDCS and weak transcranial electrical stimulation: Role of "return" electrode's position and size.
        Clin Neurophysiol. 2010; 121: 1976-1978
        • Bikson M
        • Rahman A
        • Datta A
        • Fregni F
        • Merabet L
        High-resolution modeling assisted design of customized and individualized transcranial direct current stimulation protocols.
        Neuromodulation. 2012; 15: 306-315
        • Bin Yoo H
        • Ost J
        • Joos W
        • Van Havenbergh T
        • De Ridder D
        • Vanneste S
        Adding prefrontal transcranial direct current stimulation before occipital nerve stimulation in fibromyalgia.
        Clin J Pain. 2018; 34: 421-427
        • Boggio PS
        • Amancio EJ
        • Correa CF
        • Cecilio S
        • Valasek C
        • Bajwa Z
        • Freedman SD
        • Pascual-Leone A
        • Edwards DJ
        • Fregni F
        Transcranial DC stimulation coupled with TENS for the treatment of chronic pain: A preliminary study.
        Clin J Pain. 2009; 25: 691-695
        • Brown CA
        • El-Deredy W
        • Jones AK
        When the brain expects pain: Common neural responses to pain anticipation are related to clinical pain and distress in fibromyalgia and osteoarthritis.
        Eur J Neurosci. 2014; 39: 663-672
        • Brown CA
        • Jones AK
        Psychobiological correlates of improved mental health in patients with musculoskeletal pain after a mindfulness-based pain management program.
        Clin J Pain. 2013; 29: 233-244
      1. Cohen J: Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences, 2nd ed. Hillsdale, NJ, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1988

        • Cummiford CM
        • Nascimento TD
        • Foerster BR
        • Clauw DJ
        • Zubieta J-K
        • Harris RE
        • DaSilva AF
        Changes in resting state functional connectivity after repetitive transcranial direct current stimulation applied to motor cortex in fibromyalgia patients.
        Arthritis Res Ther. 2016; 18 (40-40)
        • Curatolo M
        • La Bianca G
        • Cosentino G
        • Baschi R
        • Salemi G
        • Talotta R
        • Romano M
        • Triolo G
        • De Tommaso M
        • Fierro B
        • Brighina F
        Motor cortex tRNS improves pain, affective and cognitive impairment in patients with fibromyalgia: Preliminary results of a randomised sham-controlled trial.
        Clin Exp Rheumatol. 2017; 35: 100-105
        • Dasilva AF
        • Mendonca ME
        • Zaghi S
        • Lopes M
        • Dossantos MF
        • Spierings EL
        • Bajwa Z
        • Datta A
        • Bikson M
        • Fregni F
        tDCS-induced analgesia and electrical fields in pain-related neural networks in chronic migraine.
        Headache. 2012; 52: 1283-1295
        • DaSilva AF
        • Truong DQ
        • DosSantos MF
        • Toback RL
        • Datta A
        • Bikson M
        State-of-art neuroanatomical target analysis of high-definition and conventional tDCS montages used for migraine and pain control.
        Front Neuroanat. 2015; 9: 89
        • De Ridder D
        • Vanneste S
        Occipital nerve field transcranial direct current stimulation normalizes imbalance between pain detecting and pain inhibitory pathways in fibromyalgia.
        Neurotherapeutics. 2017; 14: 484-501
        • Dworkin RH
        • Turk DC
        • Wyrwich KW
        • Beaton D
        • Cleeland CS
        • Farrar JT
        • Haythornthwaite JA
        • Jensen MP
        • Kerns RD
        • Ader DN
        Interpreting the clinical importance of treatment outcomes in chronic pain clinical trials: IMMPACT recommendations.
        J Pain. 2008; 9: 105-121
        • Fagerlund AJ
        • Hansen OA
        • Aslaksen PM
        Transcranial direct current stimulation as a treatment for patients with fibromyalgia: A randomized controlled trial.
        Pain. 2015; 156: 62-71
        • Fallon N
        • Chiu Y
        • Nurmikko T
        • Stancak A
        Altered theta oscillations in resting EEG of fibromyalgia syndrome patients.
        Eur J Pain. 2018; 22: 49-57
        • Fayaz A
        • Croft P
        • Langford RM
        • Donaldson LJ
        • Jones GT
        Prevalence of chronic pain in the UK: A systematic review and meta-analysis of population studies.
        BMJ Open. 2016; 6e010364
        • Ferrucci R
        • Mameli F
        • Guidi I
        • Mrakic-Sposta S
        • Vergari M
        • Marceglia S
        • Cogiamanian F
        • Barbieri S
        • Scarpini E
        • Priori A
        Transcranial direct current stimulation improves recognition memory in Alzheimer disease.
        Neurology. 2008; 71: 493-498
        • Foerster A
        • Yavari F
        • Farnad L
        • Jamil A
        • Paulus W
        • Nitsche MA
        • Kuo MF
        Effects of electrode angle-orientation on the impact of transcranial direct current stimulation on motor cortex excitability.
        Brain Stimul. 2019; 12: 263-266
        • Foerster ÁS
        • Rezaee Z
        • Paulus W
        • Nitsche MA
        • Dutta A
        Effects of cathode location and the size of anode on anodal transcranial direct current stimulation over the leg motor area in healthy humans.
        Front Neurosci. 2018;
        • Foerster BR
        • Nascimento TD
        • DeBoer M
        • Bender MA
        • Rice IC
        • Truong DQ
        • Bikson M
        • Clauw DJ
        • Zubieta J-K
        • Harris RE
        Excitatory and inhibitory brain metabolites as targets and predictors of effective motor cortex tDCS therapy in fibromyalgia.
        Arthritis Rheumatol (Hoboken, NJ). 2015; 67: 576
        • Fregni F
        • Gimenes R
        • Valle AC
        • Ferreira MJ
        • Rocha RR
        • Natalle L
        • Bravo R
        • Rigonatti SP
        • Freedman SD
        • Nitsche MA
        A randomized, sham‐controlled, proof of principle study of transcranial direct current stimulation for the treatment of pain in fibromyalgia.
        Arthritis Rheum. 2006; 54: 3988-3998
        • Gracely RH
        • Ambrose KR
        Neuroimaging of fibromyalgia.
        Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol. 2011; 25: 271-284
        • Hallett M
        Transcranial magnetic stimulation: A primer.
        Neuron. 2007; 55: 187-199
        • Hazime FA
        • Baptista AF
        • de Freitas DG
        • Monteiro RL
        • Maretto RL
        • Hasue RH
        • Joao SMA
        Treating low back pain with combined cerebral and peripheral electrical stimulation: A randomized, double-blind, factorial clinical trial.
        Eur J Pain. 2017; 21: 1132-1143
        • Higgins JPT
        • Green S
        Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions.
        2011 (Version 5.1. 0 [Updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available at:) (Accessed June 18, 2020)
        • Hsu TY
        • Juan CH
        • Tseng P
        Individual Differences and state-dependent responses in transcranial direct current stimulation.
        Front Hum Neurosci. 2016; 10: 643
        • Jales Junior LH
        • Costa MdDL
        • Jales Neto LH
        • Ribeiro JPM
        • Freitas WJSdN
        • Teixeira MJ
        Transcranial direct current stimulation in fibromyalgia: Effects on pain and quality of life evaluated clinically and by brain perfusion scintigraphy.
        Revista Dor. 2015; 16: 37-42
        • Jones AK
        • Huneke NT
        • Lloyd DM
        • Brown CA
        • Watson A
        Role of functional brain imaging in understanding rheumatic pain.
        Curr Rheumatol Rep. 2012; 14: 557-567
        • Khedr E
        • Sharkawy E
        • Attia A
        • Ibrahim Osman N
        • Sayed Z
        Role of transcranial direct current stimulation on reduction of postsurgical opioid consumption and pain in total knee arthroplasty: Double randomized clinical trial.
        Eur J Pain. 2017; 21: 1355-1365
        • Khedr EM
        • Omran EA
        • Ismail NM
        • El-Hammady DH
        • Goma SH
        • Kotb H
        • Galal H
        • Osman AM
        • Farghaly HS
        • Karim AA
        Effects of transcranial direct current stimulation on pain, mood and serum endorphin level in the treatment of fibromyalgia: A double blinded, randomized clinical trial.
        Brain Stimul. 2017; 10: 893-901
        • Kraus D
        • Naros G
        • Bauer R
        • Khademi F
        • Leao MT
        • Ziemann U
        • Gharabaghi A
        Brain state-dependent transcranial magnetic closed-loop stimulation controlled by sensorimotor desynchronization induces robust increase of corticospinal excitability.
        Brain Stimul. 2016; 9: 415-424
        • Kraus D
        • Naros G
        • Guggenberger R
        • Leao MT
        • Ziemann U
        • Gharabaghi A
        Recruitment of additional corticospinal pathways in the human brain with state-dependent paired associative stimulation.
        J Neurosci. 2018; 38: 1396-1407
        • Lefaucheur J-P
        • Antal A
        • Ayache SS
        • Benninger DH
        • Brunelin J
        • Cogiamanian F
        • Cotelli M
        • De Ridder D
        • Ferrucci R
        • Langguth B
        Evidence-based guidelines on the therapeutic use of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS).
        Clin Neurophysiol. 2017; 128: 56-92
        • Mendonca ME
        • Santana MB
        • Baptista AF
        • Datta A
        • Bikson M
        • Fregni F
        • Araujo CP
        Transcranial DC stimulation in fibromyalgia: Optimized cortical target supported by high-resolution computational models.
        J Pain. 2011; 12: 610-617
        • Mendonca ME
        • Simis M
        • Grecco LC
        • Battistella LR
        • Baptista AF
        • Fregni F
        Transcranial direct current stimulation combined with aerobic exercise to optimize analgesic responses in fibromyalgia: A randomized placebo-controlled clinical trial.
        Front Hum Neurosci. 2016; 10: 68
        • Moher D
        • Shamseer L
        • Clarke M
        • Ghersi D
        • Liberati A
        • Petticrew M
        • Shekelle P
        • Stewart LA
        Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 statement.
        Syst Rev. 2015; 4
        • O'connell NE
        • Marston L
        • Spencer S
        • DeSouza LH
        • Wand BM
        Non‐invasive brain stimulation techniques for chronic pain.
        Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018; 4:CD008208
        • Opitz A
        • Yeagle E
        • Thielscher A
        • Schroeder C
        • Mehta AD
        • Milham MP
        On the importance of precise electrode placement for targeted transcranial electric stimulation.
        Neuroimage. 2018; 181: 560-567
        • Pinheiro ESdS
        • de Queirós FC
        • Montoya P
        • Santos CL
        • do Nascimento MA
        • Ito CH
        • Silva M
        • Nunes Santos DB
        • Benevides S
        • Miranda JGV
        • Sá KN
        • Baptista AF
        Electroencephalographic patterns in chronic pain: A systematic review of the literature.
        PLoS One. 2016; 11 (e0149085-e0149085)
        • Plazier M
        • Tchen S
        • Ost J
        • Joos K
        • De Ridder D
        • Vanneste S
        Is transcranial direct current stimulation an effective predictor for invasive occipital nerve stimulation treatment success in fibromyalgia patients?.
        Neuromodulation. 2015; 18: 623-629
        • Polanía R
        • Nitsche MA
        • Paulus W
        Modulating functional connectivity patterns and topological functional organization of the human brain with transcranial direct current stimulation.
        Hum Brain Mapp. 2011; 32: 1236-1249
        • Polanía R
        • Paulus W
        • Nitsche MA
        Modulating cortico‐striatal and thalamo‐cortical functional connectivity with transcranial direct current stimulation.
        Hum Brain Mapp. 2012; 33: 2499-2508
        • Radman T
        • Ramos RL
        • Brumberg JC
        • Bikson M
        Role of cortical cell type and morphology in subthreshold and suprathreshold uniform electric field stimulation in vitro.
        Brain Stimul. 2009; 2 (228.e211-213): 215-228
        • Riberto M
        • Alfieri FM
        • de Benedetto Pacheco KM
        • Leite VD
        • Kaihami HN
        • Fregni F
        • Battistella LR
        Efficacy of transcranial direct current stimulation coupled with a multidisciplinary rehabilitation program for the treatment of fibromyalgia.
        Open Rheumatol J. 2011; 5: 45
        • Schabrun SM
        • Jones E
        • Elgueta Cancino EL
        • Hodges PW
        Targeting chronic recurrent low back pain from the top-down and the bottom-up: A combined transcranial direct current stimulation and peripheral electrical stimulation intervention.
        Brain Stimul. 2014; 7: 451-459
        • Silvanto J
        • Muggleton N
        • Walsh V
        State-dependency in brain stimulation studies of perception and cognition.
        Trends Cogn Sci. 2008; 12: 447-454
        • To WT
        • James E
        • Ost J
        • Hart J
        • De Ridder D
        • Vanneste S
        Differential effects of bifrontal and occipital nerve stimulation on pain and fatigue using transcranial direct current stimulation in fibromyalgia patients.
        J Neural Transm. 2017; 124: 799-808
        • Valle A
        • Roizenblatt S
        • Botte S
        • Zaghi S
        • Riberto M
        • Tufik S
        • Boggio PS
        • Fregni F
        Efficacy of anodal transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) for the treatment of fibromyalgia: Results of a randomized, sham-controlled longitudinal clinical trial.
        J Pain Manag. 2009; 2: 353
        • Villamar MF
        • Wivatvongvana P
        • Patumanond J
        • Bikson M
        • Truong DQ
        • Datta A
        • Fregni F
        Focal modulation of the primary motor cortex in fibromyalgia using 4× 1-ring high-definition transcranial direct current stimulation (HD-tDCS): Immediate and delayed analgesic effects of cathodal and anodal stimulation.
        J Pain. 2013; 14: 371-383
      2. Wolfe F, Clauw DJ, Fitzcharles M-A, Goldenberg DL, Häuser W, Katz RL, Mease PJ, Russell AS, Russell IJ, Walitt B: 2016 Revisions to the 2010/2011 fibromyalgia diagnostic criteria. Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism, 3, 2016, 319–329

        • Wolfe F
        • Smythe HA
        • Yunus MB
        • Bennett RM
        • Bombardier C
        • Goldenberg DL
        • Tugwell P
        • Campbell SM
        • Abeles M
        • Clark P
        The American College of Rheumatology 1990 criteria for the classification of fibromyalgia.
        Arthritis Rheum. 1990; 33: 160-172
        • Zhu C-E
        • Yu B
        • Zhang W
        • Chen W-H
        • Qi Q
        • Miao Y
        Effectiveness and safety of transcranial direct current stimulation in fibromyalgia: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
        J Rehabil Med. 2017; 49: 2-9